Do I transfer shares or issue new ones?
Do I transfer shares or issue new ones? It is a question that comes up at every stage of a company’s growth, from the first co-founder arrangements through to priced funding rounds, secondary sales and employee share option and incentive programmes in scaleups.
In this article we look at when issuing new shares or transferring existing ones is more appropriate, the key legal, tax and investor-consent differences between the two, and the process involved in each, including the corporate approvals that become more important as your cap table grows.
One big takeaway here is that for any share issue or transfer, to do it properly in a way that stands up to investor due diligence, there is a specific process to follow and hoops to jump through. Openly, it can feel pedantic, but it’s important to get right as there are consequences to getting it wrong, including that the issue or transfer can be considered to never have actually happened at all. It’s better to get them right up front as they are notoriously difficult to untangle later!
You don’t need to learn this off by heart, but it’s a useful checklist.
Transfer existing shares vs Issuing new shares
The table below shows when it’s most advisable to transfer existing shares or issue new ones.
TRANSFER EXISTING SHARES(use Stock Transfer Form) | ISSUE NEW SHARES(use SH01 form) |
Gifts and Permitted Transfers Transferring existing shares is usually appropriate when gifting shares to a family member or friend for no consideration. No stamp duty is payable on a gift, although the transferor should consider capital gains tax, as gifts to anyone other than a spouse or civil partner are treated as made at market value. These types of transfers are generally defined as ‘Permitted Transfers’ in investment documents. | Investment Rounds Issuing new shares is the right route when raising investment, whether at angel, seed or Series A and beyond. The investment money goes into the company rather than to a selling shareholder, no stamp duty arises on an issue of shares, and SEIS and EIS relief is only available on newly issued shares. Secondary sales of existing shares to incoming investors do happen in later rounds, but they attract 0.5% stamp duty for the buyer and give the company no new capital. |
Transfers to Co-Founders Transferring existing shares can work when bringing in a co-founder after incorporation, ideally subject to vesting and good/bad leaver provisions in your articles or shareholders’ agreement. | Exercising Share Options Issuing new shares is the usual route when an employee exercises an option, for example under an EMI or unapproved scheme. Remember that option exercises must be reported to HMRC through the annual employment-related securities return by 6 July following the end of the tax year. |
Certain Transfers to Employees Transferring existing shares to an employee is possible, but as a company scales, share options (particularly EMI) are usually a more tax-efficient and flexible way of incentivising staff. Where shares are acquired directly, the employee should usually sign a section 431 election within 14 days. | Other scenarios – general rule Issuing new shares is generally preferable where shares are being acquired for consideration of more than £1,000, as a transfer on sale above that threshold attracts stamp duty at 0.5% (rounded up to the nearest £5), payable by the buyer, whereas an issue of new shares does not. |
Secondary Sales Transferring existing shares is the route where a founder, early employee or early investor sells part of their holding, often to an incoming investor alongside a funding round. The sale proceeds go to the selling shareholder rather than the company, so a secondary sale gives the company no new capital. The buyer pays stamp duty at 0.5% of the consideration, and the seller should consider capital gains tax (Business Asset Disposal Relief may be available where the conditions are met). Secondary sales usually engage pre-emption rights on transfer and investor consent requirements under the articles and shareholders’ agreement. Where the seller is an employee or director, the price should be supported by a valuation, as a sale above market value may be taxed as employment income. | |
Selling the company Transferring existing shares is the route on a sale of the company (share sale), where the buyer acquires all of the issued shares from the existing shareholders under a share purchase agreement. The proceeds go to the selling shareholders, the buyer pays stamp duty at 0.5% of the consideration, and sellers should consider capital gains tax and whether Business Asset Disposal Relief is available. Check the articles of associations for drag-along rights (allowing a specified majority to require minority shareholders to sell on the same terms), tag-along rights and any liquidation preference, which determines how the proceeds are split between share classes. Outstanding options will need to be dealt with, often by exercise on the sale, and convertible instruments such as ASAs or convertible loan notes will usually convert into shares before completion so that the buyer acquires 100% of the company. |
A transfer leaves the total number of shares in issue unchanged and therefore does not dilute other shareholders, whereas an issue increases the share capital and dilutes existing holders. Both, however, require the cap table, register of members and, where relevant, the PSC register to be updated. As the table above shows, the right choice usually turns on who receives the money, the tax position and whether investor consents are required.
Important considerations when dealing with company shares
IMPORTANT 1: One common pitfall is overlooking stamp duty. Stamp duty applies only to transfers of existing shares, not to the issue of new shares. Where existing shares are gifted for no consideration, no stamp duty is payable. Where existing shares are sold for more than £1,000 in total, the buyer must pay stamp duty at 0.5% of the consideration (rounded up to the nearest £5) and the stock transfer form must be submitted to HMRC within 30 days of signing. In secondary sales in later rounds, make sure the share purchase documents allocate responsibility for this cost. Make sure you speak to your accountants or tax advisors to confirm you’ve complied with your requirements.
IMPORTANT 2: Another common pitfall is around calculating the number of shares when issuing new ones. For example, let’s say that you currently have 1,000 shares in issue and want to issue 5% of the company to your co-founder, you would need to issue them approximately 53 shares (rounded up from 52.63), not 50 shares.
How is this possible? Because although 50 shares represents 5% of your existing 1,000 shares, once you issue those additional shares, the total number of shares in issue increases to 1,050. As a result, the 50 new shares would only represent approximately 4.76% of the company, rather than the agreed 5%.
You therefore need to calculate the number of shares to issue based on the total number of shares that will be in issue after the allotment. The formula is: new shares = (existing shares x target percentage) / (1 - target percentage). In a funding round, also confirm whether the percentage is to be calculated on a fully diluted basis, including the option pool and any shares to be issued on conversion of Advanced Subscription Agreements ASAs or convertible loan notes.
The process of issuing new shares easily
The process to issue new shares (bearing in mind any other investment or share option processes going on in the background) is as follows:
Determine the number and class of shares to be issued (avoiding the pitfall outlined above, and checking the fully diluted cap table)
Check directors’ authority to allot and investor consents. Where the company has more than one class of shares, directors need authority to allot under section 551 of the Companies Act 2006, granted by the articles or by ordinary resolution.
Some investment agreements also require investor majority consent for any new share issue, and new classes may require amendments to the articles or anti-dilution adjustments.
Deal with any pre-emption rights in place. A pre-emption right on transfer gives existing shareholders a right of first refusal. Statutory pre-emption rights under section 561 of the Companies Act 2006 apply to allotments for cash unless disapplied by the articles or a special resolution, and most articles and shareholders’ agreements contain contractual pre-emption rights as well. You may need your existing shareholders to:
a) waive their pre-emption rights, or
b) go through a pre-emption offer before issuing the shares. Waivers and disapplications are usually dealt with by a shareholders’ written resolution (a special resolution needs 75% of eligible votes), which can be circulated and signed electronically without holding a meeting. Any special resolution must be filed at Companies House within 15 days.
Allot the shares and file an SH01 form once the conditions are met (for example the investment agreement has completed or options have been exercised), the board approves the allotment and the subscription money is received. A completed SH01 return of allotment, must be filed at Companies House within one month of the allotment.
Issue share certificates to new shareholders. The company must issue share certificates within 2 months of the allotment. Certificates are usually executed by a director (with a witness) or by two directors, and set out the shareholder, number and class of shares and amount paid up.
Update your statutory registers and complete follow-up filings. Finally, update the register of members (the shareholder becomes a member only once entered on the register), the PSC register if anyone’s holding crosses 25%, and your cap table.
S/EIS filings (if applicable): If the shares qualify for SEIS or EIS, submit the compliance statement to HMRC so investors can receive their certificates.
The process of transferring existing shares easily
To transfer shares, the transferor signs a stock transfer form (which records the transfer from one shareholder to another), any stamp duty is paid, and the board approves registration of the transfer. The company then updates its register of members, cancels the transferor’s certificate and issues new certificates to the transferee (and to the transferor for any retained shares). If a shareholders’ agreement is in place, the transferee will usually need to sign a deed of adherence to it.
For a private company, the transfer is reported to Companies House in your next confirmation statement rather than immediately. However, if the transfer changes who is a person with significant control, the PSC register must be updated and Companies House notified within the statutory deadlines.
Alongside the basic stock transfer form, lots of transfers are also accompanied by detailed share transfer documents – the main one is a ‘share purchase agreement’ (SPA) which is typically used in company sales / M&A transactions.
Before any transfer, check the following:
If there are conditions attached to the transfer:
a) For a transfer to family members or friends, you may want the shares to carry economic rights only. The most robust way to do this is to transfer or redesignate them as a non-voting class under the articles, rather than relying on a side letter. Check also whether the recipient falls within the permitted transferee provisions of your articles.
b) For a transfer to a co-founder, you will need your co-founder agreement or shareholders agreement to establish what happens to the shares if the co-founder leaves the business.
c) For a sale to an investor or purchaser, including secondary sales in a funding round or a sale of the company, you will need a share purchase agreement setting out price, warranties and completion mechanics. Drag-along and tag-along provisions in your articles may also be engaged.
Where there are conditions, these should be recorded in a document signed by both the transferor and the transferee.
If there are restrictions on transfers, such as ‘pre-emption rights’, when there are existing investors.
As mentioned before, a pre-emption right on transfer gives existing shareholders a right of first refusal. If you want to transfer your shares, you must first offer the shares to them on terms no less favourable than those offered to the proposed buyer.
As most articles and shareholders’ agreements contain transfer pre-emption rights, check the relevant provisions first. Where they apply, the quickest route is usually for the other shareholders to waive them in writing. However, they do not normally apply to transfers to permitted transferees, such as close family members.
You should also consider whether any other consents, approvals or agreements are needed before the transfer takes place. If you are unsure, please contact us here and our team will be happy to support you.
Accelerate Law provides flexible strategic and legal support to startups and scaleups end-to-end, from angel investment rounds through to VC funding rounds and secondary sales, including share issues and transfers, cap table management, flexible funding through Advanced Subscription Agreements, and drafting and negotiating investment terms from term sheet to completion. Accelerate Law also specialises in EMI Schemes and employee equity. Contact us here or reach out to silvia.dalcin@acceleratelaw.co.uk to find out more.

